GlowGrails
First Aid Beauty Ultra Repair Firming Night Cream with Colloidal Oatmeal + Niacinamide
First Aid Beauty

Ultra Repair Firming Night Cream with Colloidal Oatmeal + Niacinamide

4.3★ · 602 Sephora reviews · #965 Sephora bestseller

  • GlowGrails score44/100i
  • Reddit signal35/100i
  • Evidence3 Reddit discussions
  • VerdictLeans negative
  • Strongest signaldry skin · eczema-prone skin
$49 at SephoraMake this personal → Add your skin type and products you like.
Why it scored 44

Leans negative

3 independent Reddit discussions · Moderate evidence

1 positive0 mixed1 negative1 neutral
Bottom line

Reddit discussion leans negative, with meaningful reservations. The strongest use-case signal is dry skin and eczema-prone skin. The most common watch-out is pilling.

People mention
dry skineczema-prone skinsensitive skin
Watch-outs
pilling

Representative discussions

Every summary links back to the source discussion.

Positiver/SkincareAddiction · 5 points

A user compares the First Aid Beauty Ultra Repair Hydra-Firm Night Cream to the Cerave Skin Renewing Night Cream and asks for opinions on the two products.

Open source →
Negativer/Sephora · 20 points

A user reports that the formulation of the First Aid Beauty Ultra Repair Cream has changed, causing pilling on their skin, and others discuss possible alternatives and the company's reformulation of several products.

Open source →
Neutralr/Sephora · 220 points

Users discuss a recall of the First Aid Beauty Ultra Repair Cream and share their experiences with the product, including a formulation change that caused pilling on one user's skin.

Open source →